Gamer Limit Banner
Avatar ImageGamer Limit Review: Portal 2
By: | April 27th, 2011 | Multi-platform
PC |PS3 |Review |Valve |X360

Fearing a tepid reception as a full standalone title, Valve first released Portal with the Orange Box alongside a host of well-established titles at a bargain price. Little did they know that just few short years later that little three-hour long bonus game would be one of the most critically acclaimed and beloved titles in recent history.

Now that they’re back to deliver a full blown sequel, one large question is raised. Does Portal 2 live up to the original, or will we need cake and grief counseling at the conclusion of this review?

After having been dragged away at the conclusion of Portal, we reassume the role of Chell in a dingy motel room. After some hilarious cognitive testing, players are introduced to Wheatley – a likable, yet dimwitted, personality core. In an attempt to escape from the decaying facility, the two accidentally re-activate the previous dormant GLaDOS. While, obviously still angry about you “murdering” her years ago, she’s willing to put differences aside – “for science”. Commence testing!

Visually, the game isn’t terribly impressive until you consider the architecture its running on. Portal 2 still uses the Source engine, which was first seen in Half-Life 2. Portal 2 may catch some flak from those obsessed with pristine graphics, but it’s still a far cry from ugly. On a more aesthetic note, the Aperture Laboratories have fallen into a state of disrepair. Centuries without maintenance have caused the labs to fall apart and become overgrown with vegetation. This gives Portal 2’s environments a much darker aesthetic – leaving the sterile feel of the original behind.

Though it isn’t without a few new mechanics, Portal 2’s core gameplay remains essentially unchanged from the original Portal. Once again you will be using the Aperture Science Handheld Portal Device or “portal gun” for short. The portal gun allows players to create a pair of portals in order to solve puzzles which would normally be physically impossible.

As was the case in Portal, a great deal of the puzzle solving is focusing around the magnitude of linear momentum at which you travel through a portal, or as GLaDOS puts it “speedy thing goes in, speedy thing comes out”. As fun as the classic portal gameplay still is, the gimmick is no longer new and doesn’t feel quite so unique. Luckily, Valve has a few new tricks up their sleeves.

There are a few new devices that will be integral in Portal 2’s puzzle chambers. Aerial faith plates essentially catapult players and objects a set distance through the air. Weighted cubes make a return, including a new reflective one that can divert lasers. Tractor beams will assist you in trapping and transport objects. Finally, the hard light bridge allows you to cross chasms and doubles as a shield to protect you from turrets. These new toys are a lot of fun to play with, but unfortunately aren’t used all that frequently. Perhaps, this is because of the additional gimmicks Valve has added into the equation.

Prior to the development of Portal 2, Valve hired the team of students behind 2009’s Tag: the Power of Paint. The concepts behind this game were used for new puzzle elements in Portal 2. These elements manifest themselves in the three gels that are revealed in the latter half of the game. When jumping on blue gel, Chell will be launched into the air, bouncing uncharacteristically high, whereas running over orange gel will speed up her movement considerably. Finally, covering a surface with white gel allows you to create portals on that surface. These gel are considerable game changers as well, but aren’t quite as fun to use as the aforementioned devices.

Unfortunately, the clever physics-based puzzle solving is less present in Portal 2. While that still exists, there is a large portion of the game where puzzling takes a back seat to exploration of Aperture Science’s underbelly. While from a narrative perspective this portion of the game is incredibly interesting, from a gameplay standpoint it is an exercise in frustration.

Much of the gameplay in the exploration portion of the game comes down to finding the one place where you can place a portal in order to progress. While it serves to provide a break between the challenging test chambers, playing Valve’s three dimensional, monochromatic take on Where’s Waldo quickly becomes frustrating. Rather than the usual rewarding sense of achievement, moving on from these areas comes with a sense of relief that a painful step of the journey is over.

The writing in Portal was fantastic.  While things no longer feel so new and exciting, Portal 2 does wonders for fleshing out the underbelly of the Half-Life universe and telling the sordid history of Aperture Science. The dialog and characterization of GLaDOS and Wheatley is particularly interesting and hilarious. Fantastic voice acting and a wonderful script make Portal 2 one of the most genuinely funny titles on the market.

Unfortunately, the narrative in Portal 2 is handicapped by an interesting design choice. Frequent loading screens make the experience feel incredibly disjointed, which is disappointing because the original Portal tackled this problem in a way that made the experience virtually seamless. Players flowed from one level to the next in an elevator – similar to those of Mirror’s Edge or the door sequences in Resident Evil. Going back to loading screens with a progress bar feels like a definite step back for the series.

After you’ve completed the campaign, the story continues in the co-operative mode with a pair of charming robotic protagonists: P-Body and Atlas. If you think the co-operative mode is just a rehash of the single player campaign that you can play with a friend you’d be sorely mistaken. In typical Valve style, the co-op mode has been designed from the ground up to offer players a brilliant multiplayer experience. Sharing those “aha moments” with a friend in your mutual discovery of puzzle solutions, and the fun you can have with four portals showcases the brilliance of the series and its seminal concept.

While Valve has boasted interconnectivity with Steam, the PlayStation Network is currently experiencing technical difficulties (read: hackers). Luckily, Valve has included split-screen multiplayer. Additionally, PlayStation 3 copies generously come bundled with a code for the PC version of the game.

Does Portal 2 outshine its predecessor? That’s a difficult question to answer. It is a longer, fuller experience to be certain, but having previously seen and experienced what made Portal so interesting and unique, Portal 2 doesn’t quite feel so new or exciting. Some frustrating decisions and an underwhelming second act aside, the central premise is as brilliant as ever and Valve has enough tricks up their sleeves to keep it challenging, interesting, and hilarious as always.

  1. I completely agree with the “8″ – I found Portal 2 completely enthralling, but it wasn’t quite as great as it’s predecessor. Nothing, in my opinion, really had that “wow” factor outside of Wheatley’s character.

    I also found GLaDOS to be kind of bland here: maybe it was just the fact that she was completely upstaged by Stephen Merchant.

    • avatar The great and only John Rambo

      The part with Cave Johnson and the 1960s 1970s and up of aperture science is so epic and GLaDOS was as entertaining as ever imo

  2. avatar Ferahtsu

    Learning about the history and downfall of Aperture science was the highlight of this title. Also, the Borealis room was cool

  3. avatar Nico

    This review was based on how portal 2 wasnt better than portal 1. But this way it doesnt make justice for people that havent played first one. To me that i have played only second one portal 2 is 11/10. I respect the reviewer but i think when he was reviewing this game he was trying to find differences between this and the first game and didnt focus on the fun factor of this one. I mean if you rate 8/10 this one what are you gonna rate 10/10. Games like portal 2 come once every few years.

    • If I ever give a game a perfect score I’ll be surprised.

    • avatar Ansar

      @Wasomacosalo Not the way i pronounce it- it snudos more like the CH in Challenge if that helps at all. of course i have been told i could be wrong.I think it would be a little embarrassing if i have this entire time but that’s how my friend told me it was pronounced

  4. avatar Braddicus

    This review is utterly biased. Based on this score, I should pass on Portal 2, and go check out “The Next Big Thing.” You’ve ruined any credibility Gamer Limit may have had.

    What are you comparing the game to for presentation? From front end UI, to the incredible level design, to the amazing realization of the co-op characters, Portal 2 sets a new bar in terms of Gameplay presentation.

    • Francisco reviewed The Next Big Thing – Kyle is reviewing Portal 2 – the reviews cannot in any way shape or form be compared. Reviews are by nature subjective, and both parties will have differing opinions.

  5. avatar StonCuld

    I think that maybe your review is a little too comparative to the first Portal game. I noticed that your review appears to be the lowest score that there is out of all the reviews I have seen Maybe you should go back and critique your own process of reviewing games. By saying too comparative I mean should you really base your score merely on comparing it to the first game. I just think that there are too many jaded critics reviewing games. I guess someone has to be the bad guy though, so it looks like your it dude! Why does everyone keep bring Half Life into this equation because they were both on the Orange Box and it uses that engine? I heard several people hoping for a tie in and maybe that is some of the let down with this game. I am glad that they are not doing this. The Half Life titles were ok at best but seem to drag on and be very repetitive so to stew that in with the Portal universe would have been a big mistake in my opinion. Anyway to wrap it up Try to have fun and not be so jaded.

  6. avatar StonCuld

    HAHAHAHA! I just saw you gave DJ Hero a 9! 9? WTF? You lost all cred as a serious critic with me. You gave that a 9 and Portal 2 a 8? Your an idiot. Find new work dude.

    • I’ve neither ever played nor reviewed DJ hero.

    • avatar Samukinha

      When I first saw Siri, I thought she was? aeomwse.When I started using Siri, I found that she was useless.Now I know I won’t use Siri again until someone exchanges her core with GLaDOSiri!

  7. avatar Someone

    Look at any of the pictures you’Ve provided above, look and them closely, you really think this game deserve a 7 on presentation and is a little improvement on the first portal ????

    maybe you should play the first portal again to see how ugly it was side by side with the second, how empty the rooms where etc etc

    Portal 1 was a teaser of what portal 2 is

  8. avatar Anonymous

    Portal 2 its just a good. Not a great game (some times boring). And once finished there is no reason to play it again. My score 7.

  9. avatar Grover Monserrat

    Hi Kes,If the difficulty is really a username/password dilemma and you are not able to log in then I am not sure what’s wrong. I tested it a second ago and it seemed to be working fine. Could you check yet again and see if it’s ok now?

  10. avatar Eddie Leggitt

    Hi, the first letter was sent to my billing address, not my shipping address. I do not know if it is just me or other people today had this difficulty but I just wished to let you guys know. It was definitely disappointing not getting the letter where I am suitable now!

  11. avatar property for sale and to rent London

    property for sale and to rent London Battersea and sw8

  12. avatar Marleen Iarussi

    I got what you mean , regards for putting up.Woh I am delighted to find this website through google. “You must pray that the way be long, full of adventures and experiences.” by Constantine Peter Cavafy.

  13. avatar Mohammad Mettille

    I would like to voice my admiration for your kind-heartedness supporting visitors who require help on that content. Your real dedication to passing the solution throughout turned out to be especially important and has frequently empowered professionals just like me to achieve their pursuits. Your entire important tutorial can mean a whole lot a person like me and somewhat more to my mates. Regards; from everyone of us.

  14. avatar

    This web site is simply fantastic, the details is updated and also clear. I am going to definitely see this website once more. I’m sorry if my English isn’t good enough, i am actually a Spanish foreign language presenter, sorry about that. Keep up with the good work:-RRB-.

  15. avatar Spy Shop London

    The London Spy Shop Has All You need in spy cameras and bugs.

  16. avatar Lawrence

    Hi my loved one! I wanht too say thzt his post is amazing, nijce written andd comme wwith almost all vita
    infos. I’d like to liok more possts like this .

    My website (Leonel)

  17. avatar Jerrie Leinwand

    I’d like to live on Kauai. It was small, quiet, and it had lots of opportunities for an adventure.

Leave a Reply