Gamer Limit Banner
Avatar ImageGamer Limit Dual Review: Heavy Rain
By: | March 5th, 2010 | Playstation 3
PS3 |Review

[Check out Jeff's second opinion in this updated review!]

With one of the biggest marketing campaigns for a video game in recent history, Heavy Rain arrived under a shadow of uncertainty. Quantic Dream had claimed that their latest title was, without doubt, the most interactive video game ever made. Early reviews, on the other hand, remarked more upon its imperfect execution rather than its ability to entertain.

For such a huge release, and under the expectation that each player’s experience would be entirely different to everyone else, it seemed only fitting that Gamer Limit allowed two writers to review Heavy Rain.

Read on to find out if we have indeed entered a new age of gaming.

I may be a fan of Jim Sterling and his ability to piss off 90% of the gaming community, but that doesn’t mean that I take his absurd “journalism” any more seriously than you.

It should come as no surprise, then, to learn that I took his pre-release Heavy Rain review with a grain of salt. While he touched on several worrisome points in the article, I still had faith that the Fahrenheit developer would be able to pull off a massive victory for interactive gaming.

Right from the get-go, playing Heavy Rain is something entirely different to the norm. Even something as simple as moving your character is turned on its head to suit the PS3 controller. While this is at first frustrating, you’ll soon come to understand the need for such a dramatic overhaul in peripheral logistics.

Quick Time Events are core to Heavy Rain, and adjusting your styling of gaming to suit is imperative. While I’ll be the first person to picket against the overuse of QTE – and trust me, there are plenty in this game that are unnecessary, if not downright ridiculous – Quantic Dream has managed to use this oft-despised feature to their advantage. I dare say that there was no moment in the game more thrilling than racing along a highway, against traffic, while scanning the screen for the next QTE in order to save my character from certain death. And that sequence is just one of many.

I’m not going to bore you with plot points, because frankly, you need to let the story unfold in front of your eyes. Heavy Rain believes in its story entirely, and if you are unable to delve into the world of a serial killer and their victims, you won’t be able to appreciate Quantic Dream’s offering for what it is.

Throughout the game you will command four main characters, as well as a couple of sub-characters as the story progresses; fans of Fahrenheit will doubtless enjoy the fan-service paid to them in one particular sequence. The story unfolds much like a book, which isn’t surprising considering the sort of wrap this game was getting from its developers throughout production. Each “sequence” could be considered a chapter, and you are given a wide range of options at any one time; you may decide to do everything possible to obtain specific information or items, or you may choose to do nothing at all – all choices have consequences.

This is where the excitement of Heavy Rain lies: in the ability to see the consequences of your actions. Whether these actions are as vast as once proclaimed by the developer is debatable, but the fact of the matter is that there is something truly invigorating about knowing that, without your intervention, your character could die at any moment.

I like to think that I have a high tolerance for bugs and glitches; game testing will do that to you. However, when a title has been so heavily touted as providing an “interactive experience”, one expects to be delivered a near-perfect piece of gaming.

Heavy Rain is no such title. It’s actually quite depressing to see a game that has so much intensity, and such a unique outlook on how a game can be played, fall victim to bugs that should have been picked up in, if not the early stages of production, at least the final once over before the game was shipped. Quantic Dream should take a long hard look at their QA department and apologize to their supportive fans – they definitely don’t deserve a broken game.

Unfortunately, the flaws in Heavy Rain are going to be made more prominent than the elements that make it such an entertaining game. Audio cuts out at random moments, putting speech bizarrely out of sync. Loading screens freeze, characters glitch and catch when walking around objects, and fellow Gamer Limit staff members have even experienced outright system crashes. While I can’t attest to the last problem, I encountered every other bug on more than one occasion.

Flaws are flaws, and there isn’t much we can do about it now. Let’s just hope that Quantic Dream releases a patch fast so that more gamers can enjoy what all of their time and effort has produced.

It’s a strange thing writing about a game that has so many problems, but still thinking fondly of it on a daily basis. Sure, there are plenty of glitches. Sure, a few of the characters are stereotypical bores that do nothing more than attempt to tug at your heartstrings. And sure, the graphics are far less impressive than what the PlayStation 3 is capable of.

But Heavy Rain is something that is just so different. I can’t remember the last time a game managed to jerk me out of my seat from the sheer intensity of a situation. I haven’t immersed myself in a game’s storyline as much as Heavy Rain’s for years, and I doubt I’ll emotionally connect to so many characters anytime soon.

Naysayers will have a cry, and they’ll complain that they didn’t get the whole package; after all, Heavy Rain is a victim of its own hype – like so many others. But when you look past all the imperfections and tattered edges, you may just find something that gaming has been waiting for.

Rating Category
6.5 Presentation
Character models are extremely disappointing, but the city itself, and the beautiful rain-drenched environments are exceptional.
How does our scoring system work?
9.0 Gameplay
The glitches will doubtlessly frustrate some gamers, but don’t let that take away from the originality and intensity involved in each sequence.
9.0 Sound
The music plays an integral role in Heavy Rain, and it will doubtless have an impact on your decisions.
8.0 Longevity
One playthrough will only set you back about 8-10 hours, but with so many different options made available, you may very well be heading back for a second or third turn.
8.0 Overall
Heavy Rain is a flawed gem. The glitches are disappointing – Quantic Dream certainly knows that. But what lies beneath is so exquisite that you should make up your own mind about it.

A second opinion: by Jeff Effendi

While it’s only been a week or so since Heavy Rain’s release, the addition of another, more delayed perspective has been beneficial for this alternate opinion. The hype train’s slowed a little, and so has my fat-kid-in-a-cake-shop excitement regarding Quantic Dream’s latest QTE. I’ve had more time to think through my experiences with the game, more Heavy Rain-based articles by Jim Sterling to read, and all the time in the world to gather my thoughts.

You’ve probably heard it before, but Heavy Rain isn’t your run-of-the-mill game. You can’t classify it as an action adventure, a shooter, an RPG and what have you; it’s a game based on how quick you respond to floating buttons on-screen. As tedious as it sounds, you’ll be surprised to find that it actually scores some points for being immersive. You, as a gamer, control almost every action that’s taking place. Whether it’s taking out your asthma inhaler, brushing your teeth, or pulling the trigger of a gun; you’re in control. When you’re playing as Dad of the Year, Ethan, you’re right inside his shoes. When you’re playing as drug-addicted FBI profiler, Norman Jayden, you go through the motions he is.

That’s what’s commendable about Heavy Rain; the developers clearly wanted you to be absorbed by these characters, and they succeed in nearly every respect. With numerous personal moments only you get to witness, from Ethan’s ‘challenges’ to Scott’s visits to the victims’ families, they have a sense of ‘home’ to them. You’re no longer a stranger playing this videogame, you’ve been invited to see their world and solve their crime. In that sense, it resonates on a personal level.

Along the grizzly rain-drenched adventure, moral choices also play a significant role later in the endgame. The moments in Heavy Rain, while limited, were intense and well done. While the purposes of some of the scenes come across as obscure or ambiguous at times, most of them become relevant as you close in on the Origami Killer. Almost every scene seems to play a part, and almost every moment feels intensely gripping. Not every game can get you to cringe, laugh, shout, sympathize and hate. Even so, to me, only Heavy Rain has succeeded in allowing its players to empathize with its characters.

Right, onto the experiences I hated. Despite all the elegance of the game’s polished production, engaging moral choices and palm-soaking scenes, Heavy Rain does trip over at times.

Firstly, some of the scenes were so damn pointless to the game’s climatic end. For a videogame that runs for less than 10 hours, Quantic Dream could’ve filled every ‘chapter’ with a purpose. There are not a whole lot of scenes in the game, and while most carry significance, those that aren’t should’ve been scrapped. In fact, these chapters even at times provide for plot holes that aren’t addressed by the end of the game. This is wasted space; they could’ve added more weight and meaning to the story if only they omitted the useless scenes. Just like a TV show, the number of episodes in a season means that every episode counts. Filler episodes, just like Heavy Rain’s obscure scenes, do not impress and add nothing to the ‘show.’

Second, the characters move like PlayStation Home avatars. As you all know, these avatars move like Sean Kingston… except they’re thinner. They’re painfully sluggish and take you right off the immersion during the more ‘physical’ moments of the game. When you’re looking for your kid in a shopping mall or a subway station, you don’t stroll or power walk, Ethan, you run. The character movements are extremely stiff at times, and they may even work against you during the time-limited scenes in the game. Holding down R2 to walk doesn’t make any sense to me. Characters can get ‘stuck’ in the environment; you can fiddle for a good 5-10 seconds just to try and get out of that one, stupid spot. For a game that relies on immersion and emotional involvement, not being able to rush and run during the urgent moments is dumb.

All in all, Heavy Rain is still undoubtedly one of the most intense entertainment experiences of my life. There are a few things that are to be noted though before we wrap up – mainly disagreements with Simon’s view on the game. The visuals, while they aren’t Uncharted 2, boast some of the most detailed character models this generation. Personally, I didn’t experience any glitches, bugs, freezes and/or system crashes either. I think the Origami Killer twist was underwhelming, and David Cage and his team could’ve done more to answer every plot hole while keeping the ‘shock value’ of the killer’s identity intact.

Heavy Rain isn’t so much a videogame as it is an experience. It doesn’t supersede its older brother, Indigo Prophecy, in terms of ambience and gameplay, but it does provide an enthralling, emotionally involving experience that you won’t find anywhere else. It’s a game that certainly creates a sense of urgency successfully, unlike a certain BioWare game.

Just picture Megan Fox and her eyebrow-raising thumb and compare it to Heavy Rain: sure she’s flawed, but let’s be fair and admire the whole package. Megan Heavy Rain, I love you.

Alternate opinion overall score: 9.0/10

  1. I’m waiting for more impressions before I decide to pick it up. I still have my $60 fully paid off reservation sitting at Gamestop.

    Thanks for the review, Simon! I can’t wait to hear Jeff’s experiences.

  2. The real question is: Will my girlfriend like it? :)

    • If your girlfriend likes CSI or Law and Order, then this is the perfect game for her.

    • Anyone who doesn’t like videogames, or is skeptical about them, should watch you play Heavy Rain. My dad, who’s pretty much indifferent, sat down to watch me play a scene from the game and said “you know, you should play more games like this. It looks like a movie!” And while he’s not 100% right regarding HR being movie-like, it is a pretty accessible game.

  3. avatar DeRp~

    “Character models are extremely disappointing,” “And sure, the graphics are far less impressive than what the PlayStation 3 is capable of.” – This is where I stopped taking your review seriously. Take off your Xbox fanboy goggles, buddy.

    • For as much as Cage talked up the graphics as being the “best thing ever made”, Uncharted 2 looks much better, imo.

    • The game didn’t look as fantastic as it was pumped up to be. And with the weird camera angles it was hard to get a feel for how well the details were really done.

    • The fact is that Sony’s PR team ASSURED gamers that Heavy Rain’s graphics would top Uncharted 2′s. Show me some evidence that backs up that statement.

      The environments are beautiful, but the character models are shocking in-game. The bandages on Ethan, for example, looked like something out of a PS2 game.

      Prove me wrong, kids. Prove me wrong. ;)

    • Yeah Simon, go back to playing Gaylo 3. Heavy Rain is PROOF that the PS3 is completely superior to your stupid 360! Why can’t you give us the unbiased review we deserve? This game deserves a 10 out of 10! David Cage told me so!

  4. avatar Surion

    What a fucking bunch of crap in this review

  5. How wrong is it my favorite part of the review was the shot at another site’s reviews editor?

  6. I had the Demo freeze my PS3 when I took a long time at the crime scene. Everyone present agreed that an in game Nuke was set off and all the characters died

    • Well then it was a pretty accurate demo… cause the game froze up at least 5 times in my 8 hr playthrough. That’s not even counting the numerous audio glitches.

    • avatar Koustav

      Zune and iPod: Most group study the Zune to the Jot, but after seeing how thin and sinlrusirgpy flyspeck and frivolous it is, I ponder it to be a rather single crossbreed that combines qualities of both the Take and the Nano. It’s really iridescent and lovely OLED select is slightly smaller than the advert impede, but the contestant itself feels quite a bit smaller and ignitor. It weighs some 2/3 as more, and is noticeably small in width and level, while state righteous a whisker thicker.

  7. avatar Josh

    Sorry, I need to vent about this game. This will probably be longer than the actual article itself. >_< I was so excited to try it out after all the hype it was getting. I'm disappointed…to say the least.

    Maybe it's my ridiculously short attention span, but after playing for over 2.5 hours, I feel like nothing happened. The story was JUST slowly starting to unravel. Doesn't cut it for me. I need something to grab my attention within the first ten minutes—whether its something scary, graphic, a beautiful visual…anything really.

    They should've taken some advice from CSI. The episodes start off with a hook to get you drawn in. Usually the most shocking scenes are in the beginning before the opening credits. How did Heavy Rain start? It started with me wasting an hour setting the table for dinner and listening to bad child voice acting.

    Now onto the graphics… Cutting edge? I don't think so. I feel like Uncharted 2 blew this away. No arguing. Personally, I think the characters are ugly (my friend says that's what makes them realistic—not being perfect). I mean, of course there should be some sort of haggardness to reflect the mood and setting of the game, but please just make them look like normal people. The wife looked like an elf, most of them had gigantic ears. The dad who lost his kid and the matrix-y police officer looked similar. I got confused between the two for a hot second in the beginning. The character movements are the most ridiculous part. They move like the people in The Sims. Not The Sims 2 or 3. Just the first one. They're ridiculously stiff and the walking / slow reactions seem even worse than the old Silent Hill games. I got stuck in corners constantly.

    I kept hearing "it's like playing through a movie." I mean…sure, I guess. A bad movie, that is. I like to consider the Uncharted games "playable" movies more so than this.

  8. avatar Coored

    Looks like either the reviewers are Xbuddies or they didn’t get any further then the boring war-games adfundum.

    • avatar Iiedha

      I like the valuable imnorfation you provide in your articles. I will bookmark your blog and check again here frequently. I’m quite certain I’ll learn a lot of new stuff right here! Best of luck for the next!

  9. avatar Jee

    Thanx for that hard work, sustain the great prfeorm Wonderful operate, I’m likely to start off a modest Web site Engine training course function making use of your internet site I am hoping you get pleasure from running a blog together with the common BlogEngine.internet.Thethoughts you express are genuinely brilliant. Wish you may proper some a lot more posts.

  10. avatar Carmel

    A fascinating discussion is definitely worth comment.

    There’s no doubt that that you should publish more about this
    subject, it may not be a taboo matter but generally people don’t discuss such topics.
    To the next! All the best!!

    Here is my blog: traffic generator software free

  11. avatar Josh Roseboom

    Wonderful collection, Eric, appreciate it. Bookmarked and shared :)

  12. avatar Doris

    This is very interesting, You are a very skilled blogger.
    I’ve joined your rss feed and look forward to seeking more of your wonderful post.
    Also, I’ve shared your website in my social networks!

    My webpage web site (Elvia)

  13. avatar Eden Rajala

    You are my intake, I have few blogs and infrequently run out from brand :) . “The soul that is within me no man can degrade.” by Frederick Douglas.

  14. avatar sepatu adidas

    saya sangat senang mengunjungi stus anda ini karena sangat bermanfaat sekali, im from indonesian sir and sorry I talking in indonesian language :)

  15. avatar Meridith

    Just wish to say your article is as surprising.
    The clearness in your post is simply great and i can assume you are an expert on this subject.
    Fine with your permission allow me to grab
    your RSS feed to keep up to date with forthcoming post. Thanks a million and
    please keep up the rewarding work.

    my blog: porcelain nerikomi 4

  16. avatar Nelson Escott

    I am only writing to let you understand what a remarkable discovery our daughter obtained viewing your site. She came to find a wide variety of issues, which included what it is like to possess a wonderful giving style to have the rest really easily learn about selected complicated issues. You really exceeded her expected results. Thank you for offering those insightful, dependable, educational and as well as easy thoughts on your topic to Mary.

  17. avatar online coupon for

    After research just a few of the blog posts in your web site now, and I truly like your means of blogging. I bookmarked it to my bookmark web site checklist and will probably be checking back soon. Pls try my website online as properly and let me know what you think.

  18. avatar Thad Dredge

    Just wanna comment on few general things, The website layout is perfect, the written content is rattling excellent : D.

Leave a Reply