Gamer Limit Banner

[Make sure you check in every Saturday, as Gamer Limit will always have an interesting editorial for you to read!]

With so much emphasis placed upon games, graphics, and online play these days, we sometimes forget about an intrinsic element to our video gaming experience; an element that we could not do without. I am talking, of course, about the controller.

Now, before half a dozen retro fanboys start jumping up and down on the spot shrieking at the insensitivity of not including the Tandy 1000 Joystick, let me preface this article by stating that I have only included the handheld masterpieces that had a huge impact on both the gaming, and popular, cultures.


Atari 2600

Atari 2600

I can only imagine what it would have been like for a kid to get home from school to a brand-spanking-new Atari 2600, complete with Pac-Man, Pitfall!, and a couple of badass joysticks.

Unfortunately, I, like so many others, missed the Atari boat due to a lack of existence. However, the 2600 joystick holds firmly onto our opening spot for sheer interactive excellence with a single button and stick. Oh, and the sweet sensation of carpal tunnel.

Must-plays: Pitfall!, Pac-Man, Missile Command.




Looking more like Tommy Vercetti’s mobile phone, the ColecoVision’s controller was able to morph into several retro beasts better left in the bargain bin, alongside abominations like the NES Power Glove.

Still, being able to slip your controller into a nifty Driving Expansion Module, complete with steering wheel and pedal, was a pretty revolutionary idea, and would pave the way for a handful of similar devices on future consoles.

Must-plays: Dragonfire, Fathom, WarGames, Zaxxon.


Atari 5200


Just like ColecoVision, Atari “borrowed” the idea for their controller from Mattel’s Intellivision. However, a few extra months off the market allowed the 5200 controller to top the ColecoVision, with double the amount of buttons, number pad, and the familiar Start, Pause, and Reset thumb-bashers.

Despite its remarkable number of buttons, however, the Atari 5200 system is generally considered to be a market failure, as it was unable to compete with the veritable “Atari 2600 emulator”, ColecoVision.

Must-plays: Space Dungeon, Qix, Rescue On Fractalus!


Nintendo Entertainment System (NES)


With a revolutionary system came a revolutionary controller. No longer was vertical the way of the gamer; now, a horizontal controller allowed players to reach every single button without excessive or awkward movement.

There are far too many accessories (52 that we could find) to name here. But let’s just say that the NES Zapper for Duck Hunt kicked ass, while the Laserscope… well… didn’t.


Must-plays: Super Mario Bros. 3, Mega Man 2, The Legend of Zelda, Punch-Out.


Sega Master System

Sega Master System

While the Master System itself looked more like an oversized tape-recorder, the controller was quite clearly inspired by the success of the NES. Black as a Sega fanboy’s hatred for Nintendo, the Master System controller boasted merely a D-pad and two buttons, with the 1 button doubling as the Start function.

In 1990, despite the success of Sega’s new Mega Drive system, they bought back the rights to the Master System from Tonka, and released the aptly named Sega Master System II. If it weren’t for the fact that you could play Alex Kidd in Miracle World without even inserting a cartridge into the system, the SMSII wouldn’t even warrant mentioning.

Must-plays: Wonder Boy in Monster Land, Phantasy Star, Alex Kidd in Miracle World.


Sega Mega Drive/Sega Genesis

Sega Mega Drive

It’s time to wave goodbye to palm indentations caused by rectangular controllers, because the ergonomic (sort of) Sega Mega Drive is here. A D-pad, complete with A, B, C, and Start buttons were all you needed in the days when Sonic and Altered Beast weren’t the laughing stock of the gaming community.

I’ll always have fond memories of “Up, Down, Left, Right, A, Start” for giving me the opportunity to bypass that crappy Marble Zone.

Must-plays: Sonic the Hedgehog, Streets of Rage, FIFA International Soccer.


Super Nintendo Entertainment System (SNES)


Still regarded as one of the greatest consoles to have ever been released, the SNES offered a remarkable fourth generation controller that included the standard buttons with a couple of new shoulders.

Still used fervently in next-gen consoles today, the shoulders allowed players to utilize more features, using more fingers, in shorter periods of time. Do your worst, arthritis!

Must-plays: Earthbound, Chrono Trigger, Super Metroid.


Sega Saturn

Sega Saturn

A massive flop outside of Japan, I had the pleasure of consistent game time on one of these badboys thanks to a cousin of mine. Though it didn’t have anything on my Playstation, it did offer some pretty incredible games including Panzer Dragoon, and an entire army of Virtua titles.

Featuring both CD and cartridge drives, with the ability to play any standard music CD, the Saturn eventually found its way to the bottom of the bargain bin alongside its uglier cousin, the DVD/VCR combo.

Must-plays: Panzer Dragoon Saga, NiGHTS into Dreams, Virtua Cop.




The Playstation revolutionized not only the way we play games, but also the way we use our hands to dictate them. After the standard PSX and dual analog controllers, Sony believed they had stumbled onto a near-perfect handheld design in the DualShock; a claim backed up by their 2007 Emmy Award for “Peripheral Development and Technological Impact of Video Game Controllers”.

And who am I to argue with the Emmys? Even though the Nintendo 64 had a single analog stick in 1996, the DualShock controller has been partnered with every Sony console since 1997, and allows the gamer to use both the standard D-pad as well as the more sensitive analog sticks.

Must-plays: Metal Gear Solid (PSX), Final Fantasy VIII (PSX), Tekken 3 (PSX), Shadow of the Colossus (PS2), GTA: San Andreas (PS2), Kingdom Hearts (PS2), Killzone 2 (PS3), Valkyria Chronicles (PS3), Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots (PS3).


Nintendo 64

Nintendo 64

After the new boy Sony made such a splash on the market, Nintendo had to come up with something unique in order to counter the massive wave of Playstation gamers. And, being Nintendo, they did exactly that.

Enter, stage left, the three-legged freak known only as the N64 controller. Despite its awkward shape, Nintendo managed to fit ten buttons in total onto the M-shaped thingy, with a handy backside that was clear for a bit of Rumble Pak action.

Must-plays: GoldenEye, Super Mario 64, The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time.


Sega Dreamcast

Sega Dreamcast

Still by far my most favored of all console controllers, regardless of the lack of a second analog stick. The Dreamcast one-upped the 64’s idea of an open back by doubling the memory card slot availability, and adding two triggers to the rear of the controller.

And it was definitely the memory card that was the pièce de résistance of the Dreamcast controller. Take a pinch of Sega’s Visual Memory Unit, add a splash of Sonic Adventure, and hey presto! your very own portable Tamagotchi!

Well, something had to make up for that ridiculously placed lead.

Must-plays: Shenmue, Sonic Adventure, Jet Set Radio Future.


Nintendo Gamecube


Once again, Nintendo tried to push the envelope with the Gamecube, and it is crystal clear what they were trying to achieve. However, they ultimately ended up with an oddly shaped controller that could simply not compete with the likes of the DualShock and the Xbox Type-S controller.

Still, I have many fond memories of holidaying with Nintendo-loving cousins playing Sega Soccer Slam, and the highly underrated Star Fox Adventures.

Must-plays: Resident Evil 4, Metroid Prime, Super Smash Bros. Melee.


Microsoft Xbox


The original Xbox is not only father to one the most ridiculously obnoxious controllers in video game history, but also to one of the greatest. The original Duke controller managed to piss off nearly every Microsoft fan except the Japanese. Luckily for them, they got a hold of the Type-S well before the rest of the world.

Still, once the Type-S hit the open market, it was obvious that the Xbox had found a soul mate, and would go on to form the basis for Microsoft’s seventh generation controller.

Must-plays: Halo, Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic, The Chronicles of Riddick: Escape from Butcher Bay.


Microsoft Xbox 360

Xbox 360

Improving only slightly upon the Type-S design, the Xbox 360 controller followed Sony’s lead by replacing its black and white buttons with left and right bumpers above the triggers. Makes for damn good grenade throwing in Halo 3 multiplayer.

But possibly the best part about the 360 controller is that the wired version has a USB plug that can be used on most PCs. Makes for damn good emulator gaming.

Makes for damn good everything!

Must-plays: Bioshock, Braid, Gears of War.


Nintendo Wii

Wii Controller

Taking the standard controller to the next level – and then some – only Nintendo could develop such a marvel of technology that has managed to split the gaming community.

Whatever your stance on the Wii’s innovation, the truth is that it has managed to open up the gaming market to millions of men, women, and children that would never have purchased a gaming system in their lives had it not been for titles such as Wii Fit.

For Nintendo fanboys, however, there is always the Classic Controller attachment, and Gamecube controller ports, as well as plenty of former Sega and Nintendo titles available at the Wii’s online store.

Must-plays: Super Mario Galaxy, The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess, Metroid Prime 3: Corruption.

  1. I planned on doing a similar article a while back – serves me right for dragging my feet :) really quirky, enjoyable article though! I reckon the 360 has got it spot on – though i do miss the dreamcast’s VMU compatibility!

  2. My personal history with the Dualshock wins out, but honestly, if the 360 just fixed that D-Pad it would be better for the majority of games currently on the market.

    Also, I miss running dungeons on my VMU and linking the data back to my Dreamcast – RIP.

  3. Don’t forget the VMU’s friend, the Sony PocketStation! It was only utilized in ONE game in the States, but that one game was Final Fantasy VIII and made it worth it for me to import one from Japan for $40.

    Silly me. Why didn’t it work on Street Fighter Alpha III?! It did in Japan! Grrrrr.

    Oh, and the best peripheral ever: Not sure if it counts as a CONTROLLER per se, but… well… you know.

  4. @ Header Picture….
    Are you sure that last step is considered an evolution?

  5. avatar Boz

    “But possibly the best part about the 360 controller is that the wired version has a USB plug that can be used on most PCs. Makes for damn good emulator gaming.”

    You can use the ps3 controller on the pc aswell.

  6. avatar No love for Intellivision?

    That circle-pad controller with the bubble-switch keypad and it’s plastic overlays just about broke my thumb during the early ’80s.

  7. @Boz
    Yep! You’re right: I love gaming on my PC with the controller of my choice.

    I think Simon was just referring to the fact that you can simply plug in a 360 controller with ease, and Windows (Microsoft) will automatically install the proper plugins.

    By the way, Xpadder is a GREAT way to remap keyboard keys to controller buttons and play flash games like Meat Boy.

    Edit: Oh snap. You have to pay for Xpadder now…do some google searching for an older free version.

  8. avatar Potedude

    I used to love the PS3 controller but after a few hours gaming these days it feels a little small in my hand. I start to get RSI. Especially if you need to hammer L2/R2 a lot. I love the layout though. If only they made it a little bigger…

    • avatar Lucas

      Ayrton Senna has been voted the best? driver of all time in vuorias motorsport polls, including F1 Racing Magazine’s 2004 poll? and one involving current drivers as published by the German newspaper Bild am Sonntag in July 2010. In 2009, a? poll of 217 CURRENT and FORMER Formula One drivers conducted by the British magazine Autosport named Senna as the greatest Formula One driver who ever lived .

    • avatar Tish

      By , May 8, 2009 at 11:16 amOh man, I remember those days. I was a wild child, alyaws run around, play all day. I do miss those days. Back then, I didn’t care about the clothes I wore, shoes on my feet, I got down and dirty in the sand, the mud, the construction site. Miss them so much.

    • avatar Maverick

      Exceptiones inform QuotesChimp precisely what regions are particularly perhaps not included in the insurance policy. To put it differently, where an exception exists, there’s absolutely no safety provided from the coverage (unless bought singularly as a driver or endorsementsee &#3 4;Sanctiones and Individuals&#3 4; underneath).

  9. @Potedude

    I have to agree with you on the size of the PS controller. Perhaps it’s just my hands being so adjusted to the 360, but I always find that after a few hours of Playstation action my hands start to seize up.

    I can literally play 360 for hours upon hours without that ever happening to me, though.

    • avatar Request for assistance

      I came across your comment on line. I recently purchased a used Colecovision on Ebay and unfortunately it doesn’t appear to work. Do you know of any reliable places that either repair or refurbish the Coleco system Any assisitance much appreciated MackieWilliam@AOL.COM

  10. avatar Kevin

    I was one of the kids that came home to the Atari. There was something special about that joystick. It had an organic feel to it that other controllers don’t. It may have been the rubber sheath around the stick. I don’t know. I played that thing from the time school got out until bed time.

    • avatar Andressa

      I would like to show my appreciation for your kidennss giving support to people who really need help with your study. Your personal dedication to passing the message all through ended up being unbelievably good and has in most cases allowed many people just like me to achieve their pursuits. The valuable tips and hints implies so much to me and further more to my peers. Regards; from all of us.

  11. I personally think the Xbox 360 controller is the most comfortable controller of all time. If they could fix the D-pad, I think it would pretty much be perfect.

  12. avatar Chris

    @ Shawn Evans

    exactly right. D-pad is far from perfect, but the thing just fits in your hands just right.

    Did anyone else actually LIKE the original Xbox controler? i liked it better then the controller-S by far.

  13. avatar Troy

    I like the chronology of this! (Ironically, I was assigned to write an article similar to this for a website [assigned over a month ago, w/ no knowledge of yours, just FYI.]) Mine was rather vague, however, and didn’t cite console specifics. I like how you can see the console progression here. Nicely done!

    • avatar Safaa

      wow soooo dramatic!! hahhaa it took the notebook a modest while to realize that the game wasn’t fun and was just math. I can’t believe I own this game. Why!?! Well my? mom doubtless bought it for me in view of the fact that like, you cultured math.

  14. avatar

    Controller evolution.. Keen :)

  15. avatar Tomoaki

    Please read this so anyone can help me eiethr understand or confirm something. The screen shot of the Orca chasing M. Sonic is similar to Emerald Coast. here is the problem the time clock looks to be about the time that the level starts at 0.25.87 so that would be the start of the level. When looking at Emerald Coast for Sonic Adventure on youtube the orca doesn’t chase Sonic until about a minute into gameplay. So this makes me wonder again if the level is being mixed into another level much like how Seaside hill has hydrocity and Rooftop Run has Fly battery zone element.s

    • avatar Jossiel

      Natal looks prtety Natal looks prtety awesome, this and sony motion controller are both great, there will be different genre of game benefiting the motion controller or Natal.Like Sony motion controller would be awesome for survival horrors if Doom 5 was made with it, imagine holding a torch in one hand and a gun in the other, while Natal does look impressive on fighting games genres

  16. avatar Charis

    It’s difficult to find well-informed people in this particular subject, but you seem like you know what you’re talking about!


    Also visit my weblog; company of heroes 2 cracked generator

  17. avatar Sherita

    Way cool! Some extremely valid points! I appreciate you penning this write-up
    and also the rest of the site is also really good.|

    Review my homepage – pit-37 2013 rok

  18. avatar Kandice

    It was a wonderful game that faithfully recreated a console
    Zelda adventure, but allowed you to take it on
    the go with you. All available games can be selected by
    simply walking in front of them. In Gears of War 3, fight on as Marcus Fenix, the grizzled war hero and leader of Delta Squad.
    Each of these characters has a special ability or disadvantage
    which puts a new spin on the way you play. Without a job on the force, Max has left the greater New York area, and he finds himself in
    Sao Paulo, Brazil, working in the burgeoning field of private security.

    Here is my web site – 3ds émulateur

  19. avatar Jaime

    Hi, Neat post. There’s a problem along with your website in internet explorer,
    would check this? IE nonetheless is the marketplace leader and a good part of other
    people will pass over your great writing due to this problem.

    my page; rings for men

  20. avatar Kathie

    Appreciation to my father who shared with me concerning this
    website, this web site is actually amazing.

    Feel free to surf to my site :: bing ads track social click conversion tracking

Leave a Reply