Gamer Limit Banner

sonic

Since the release of Sonic Adventure 2 in 2001, Sonic the Hedgehog has been in a coma. His 3D outings have generated limited success on the consoles while his portable endeavors have garnered rave reviews because they mastered the formula the Sega Genesis made famous. After reading about Sonic and the Black Knight (SBK) in Nintendo Power last year, I eagerly anticipated its release, hoping that it would mark the removal of the anthropomorphic blue blur from life support.

I thoroughly enjoyed the day time levels in Sonic Unleashed, so I speculated that SBK would attempt to match that speed while incorporating swordplay. I was wrong. Thanks to terrible controls, bad gameplay, crappy music, and atrocious multi-player, I pronounce the time of death on March 3, at 12:01am (PST).

sonic23

SBK is the second game in the storybook series. This series incorporates Sonic into popular stories, this one being King Arthur and the Knights of the Round Table. Sonic is dropped into the world, and after some terrible dialog; you set out to defeat a corrupted King Arthur. The Sonic universe is loosely connected to the story through the characters. Merlina, Calibrun, and King Arthur are both new characters (for the Sonic Universe) and everyone else is played by familiar faces: Amy, Tails, Shadow, Knuckles, and Blaze. The game doesn’t really follow the story of King Arthur, but instead, lets Sonic and his development team in so that they may ruin it as they please. The game’s plot is abysmal, and its only redeeming quality is its brevity, it’s four hours long. It is obvious that it was geared toward the younger generation…but so is Mario’s, and his gameplay makes up for that.

I am dedicated this paragraph to the good in SBK, so I am sorry if it is brief. SBK is an aesthetically pleasing game with big detailed environments show off what the Wii can do. It also utilizes a unique and enjoyable plot delivery system. Instead of using regular old cinematics, the game’s story plays out across a motion comic book with full voice acting. The voice work is decent but the dialog is so bad that appreciating what the actors did is difficult. The game’s unique style when telling the story and having some of the best graphics on the Wii make for an enjoyable experience when watching it or looking at screenshots. Playing the game is a different story.

sonic14

SBK is broken up into multiple zones with a multitude of stages. Each level uses a behind the back camera, (a few switch to the side) and Sonic must race to the goal while slashing bad guys. The levels have different requirements for victory: defeat so many enemies, don’t get hit, defeat said boss, and…reach the goal. There is a little variety in what your mission is, but accomplishing each mission is done the same way. Hold up on the nunchuk and shake the Wii remote. SBK requires the player to swing the remote to slash the sword but it doesn’t detect particular motions. So instead of trying to mimic the actions of the blade, the player just shakes it back and forth. With about 100 enemies per stage, the combat is mindless and boils down to running and shaking or running, stopping, and shaking. There is a soul surge meter that charges up an attack, but it’s just a slower, more accurate attack, that still requires thoughtless shaking.

About halfway through the single player the ability to select from the three bosses attempts to liven up the gameplay. However, they can’t walk and chew gum at the same time, the crux of the gameplay, and they are slower than Sonic. I used each of them once, hoping that I was only dreaming and their inclusion actually ment something. To top that off, there is noticeable lag. So instead of controlled bouts of mindless shaking, the player must shake the remote back and forth constantly to make sure their attacks are going through. It felt like I was shaking a jar of salsa for hours.

Furthermore, while you are running forward and gaining speed, moving to the left and right feels stiff. Getting red (soul surge meter) or gold fairies (rings) is difficult because you can’t react at slow or high speeds. If you do miss the item, going back for it is even harder. Sonic can’t turn around, he only backpedals. You have to jump backward a few times to get back to the item and then maneuver your way over to it. The camera never moves so when you do this, every enemy that you missed is now obscured and you will more than likely lose rings as you backtrack. It doesn’t feel like the enemies (all six types of them) and level designs are working against you, but the entire game itself (controls, story, gameplay, sound) is trying to keep you from enjoying it.

sonic31

Completing each stage gives you stars, I.D. points, and followers. Each level has a max number of followers you are allowed to earn through repeatedly beating that level, and depending on how well you do during the level determines how many followers you get. These followers act like experience, and after gathering so many, whichever fighting style you are using levels up, or you earn a new title. These fighting styles let Sonic focus on speed, swordplay, or balance. The problem with them is that it doesn’t matter which you pick, there isn’t a notable difference. The I.D. points let you identify a certain number of items after each level but these are mostly collectibles. You can equip certain items, but they’re useless. Some give you extra points to help boost your score at the end, others protect you from poison and panic (neither of which I saw at all), or you can identify items easier. The items are also tradable across the wi-fi network with your friends. It adds replay to the game but the problem is that you have to play through the game multiple times to collect all of the items. There are also unlockable videos and concept art, but like the items, they require you to play more than once. Oh yeah, the stars. The game keeps a total of how many you have earned, giving one through five depending on how well you do in a level, but I was unable to figure any other use they had.

If you can’t handle the single player mode, SBK sports a multi-player battle mode as well . Here players can battle it out under a specific “battle rule.” You can play as some of the other characters here, but the it suffers the same control problems as the single player, as well as being tacked on. The “battle rules” are lame and the character selection is limited. What I did like is that you can take your scores from certain levels and put them online. The level selection wa as limited as everything else, but it is a groundwork for future, hopefully successful, Sonic games. Imagine a good 3D Sonic game where you can post your personal best for your favorite level online or race shadows of other players. We can only hope.

sonic4

To top off the bad controls, monotonous gameplay, and awful multi-player, the sound is atrocious. The opening song sounds like an amateur rock band’s feeble attempt to make it big and the gameplay music is forgettable. Slashing and clashing sounds from swinging your sword and blocking sound off at times and your sword (since it talks) gives you tons of hints that border on infuriating rather than helpful. The sound effects are a garbled mess that someone mixed together in their garage. The only redeeming quality of the music is the tune that plays while you are in the main menu. It is the only thing that fits into the medieval canvas that Sonic has been so hastily painted onto.

I say hastily because this game feels rushed. It looks like the development team spent more time working on the game’s looks. The controls don’t function well, the gameplay is uninteresting, there is roughly six different enemies to battle, and the music (like almost everything else) is messy. I appreciate Sega’s attempt (again) to revitalize the blue blur, but his problem isn’t in variety, it’s in quality. Sonic is like the Megaman series. Both heroes have experienced success in the 2D market but haven’t hit their stride in 3D. Mario and Zelda were able to make the jump because their original gameplay mechanics, along with new ones, were transferable to the third dimension. Sonic and Megaman’s transition has been difficult, (Sonic Adventure 2 was great and I enjoyed Megaman Legends) because developers keep adding new things without first mastering the old. The Megaman series finally got the hint and, taking it a step further, made a brand new 2D 8bit game that is one of the best in the series by reestablishing that made Megaman great. Sonic needs this too. Sonic Rush, for the Nintendo DS, is an awesome platformer that proves that the old school Sonic formula is successful. I would love to see Sega develop a new, 16bit 2D platformer, an entire game using the daytime levels from Sonic Unleashed, or keep him on the portables. Take a look at Tim Turi’s “How to save Sonic the Hedgehog” article for an in-depth look at what I am talking about. Until then, Sega should give him some rest before they ruin what is left of his credibility.

Rating Category
7.5 Presentation
Detailed environments with a stylish storytelling system make for one of the best looking games on the Wii.
How does our scoring system work?
2.0 Gameplay
Atrocious controls, repetitive missions, horrible writing, and terrible multiplayer will keep even the masochists at bay
3.0 Sound
The voice acting is decent for once but the mind numbing soundtrack outwieghs any benefit.
2.0 Longevity
Not only is the game difficult to play once, getting all of the collectibles requires playing it over and over again.
3.0 Overall
It's one of the best looking games on the Wii, but fails at everything else.

  1. I can’t believe they made Sonic Unleashed, and still went on making this terrible game.

  2. Dude, this is ridiculous. they honestly either need to 1. stop making sonic games, or 2. go back to 2D. This is awful, and is making the Sonic franchise turn into a pile of poo. Goddamnit SEGA.

  3. avatar @ Timmy

    Making? Sonic has been poo since SA2.

    He should stab himself with that effing sword.

  4. avatar @Timmy @Timmy

    Amen. Adventure 1 was an amazing transition, 2 was passable, but everything after that blew. I don’t get it though; Adventure 1 was their first major 3d effort and it was the only great one.

  5. avatar Chase Cook

    Sonic Adventure was great but I really enjoyed the multiplayer (what it had) and varied gameplay that Sonic Adventure 2 offered. Mario has found success because, not only was his first game great, but the subsequent games were as well. Sonic’s attitude plays a big role because his personality dictates the plots and, at times, gameplay.

  6. Actually, this one wasn’t that bad… I would give it atleast a 6-7.
    But anyway, I had my hopes up high that sega would learn their lesson, and realize what is making their new games crap.

  7. Poor poor sonic, the torture they put him through.

  8. avatar Xander

    So…how long do you think this reviewer played the game, a say a good 5 minutes, 10 minutes tops…because he scratched the surface the game, obviously sucked at it since any player aiming for the top 20 spots on the online ranking system knows how to beat a level incredibly fast and about how precise timing is key to this game, and then said it sucked.

    Yeah…see…when I started playing it, my wrist hurt for shaking my wii remote a lot…but as I started sucking less…I reduced the amount of mindless shaking and replaced it with mindful shaking with precise timing.

  9. @Xander

    I present to you: Fanboy Friday. It’s all about fanboy review commenters who trash the reviewer. This particular piece is on Sonic and the Black Knight, and a lot of them sound a lot like you.

    http://www.destructoid.com/fanboy-friday-bag-of-douche-edition-123949.phtml

  10. avatar Xander

    But…this review really is wrong…I’m not even that big of a Sonic fan…but c’mon…this reviewer, as well as a few others, miss a lot of important details. Like this reviewer says that the soul surge is just thoughtless waving…no mention of the perfect hit which requires precise timing. Nothing about the other playable characters, nothing about the different weapons they you forge for them that change them. A lot of things are rarely touched upon and don’t go beyond “this game sucks”.

  11. avatar Chase Cook

    I apologize, I did forget to mention the perfect hit. However, the game attempts to fuse together speed and stop-go combat. I used the perfect hit soul surge only when I was using the other characters. I saw no benefit using it with Sonic. I could merely hold up and swing the remote to complete a majority of the levels. I did mention the other playable characters, but I guess I needed more detail. I stated that the game wants the player to run and slash, which these characters cannot do. I know that Sonic Team put a decent amount of content into the game, but it forces the player to play levels they have already beaten over and over again. I appreciate your commentary on this review and I will do my best to bring what I have learned from your comments into my future reviews. However, the game still sucks.

  12. The review was over 1600 words and the game probably deserved 500, Chase. Don’t worry about it. You hit a ton of points, and it was more detailed than most other reviews on the game.

  13. 1600 words?! Thats alot for a game like this. You could of probably summarised it in one sentence.

Leave a Reply