Gamer Limit Banner

I got pretty damn good at Pro, usually by playing people who didn’t really like it. I couldn’t understand why my friends (just them, my brother was a Pro Evo fiend in those days too) were not getting into it like I was. But then it happened. Pro Evo 3 came along and things changed. By the time number four came out, these guys were with me, foaming at the mouth for a match and spitting blood at the thought of anybody playing FIFA.

As time went on, new iterations arrived and things got even better. I moved in with a few of my friends and we spent hours playing one another again and again, or teaming up to try and win the World Cup with England. This usually resulted in a pitiful display at the quarter-final stage, more often than not seeing us go out at the hands of Croatia. It was a blissful time and things were due to be sent into orbit with the release of the next generation of console.

I’d lie awake at night just dreaming of what Konami would conjure up with the processing power of the Playstation 3 and Xbox 360 at its disposal. This was going to be huge, fantastic, wonderful, amazing, superb… You get the idea. I’d played Pro Evolution Soccer 6 on the 360 but not at any great length and, to be fair, it played the same as the PS2 version that I was playing constantly. This was just the beginning. What I wasn’t to know was that it was to be the beginning of the end.

FIFA usually comes out a couple of weeks before Pro Evo in Europe, and FIFA 08 was no exception. What was an exception was the fact that for the first time in a very long time FIFA was earning some stellar review scores, matching and even often trumping those on Pro Evo. I was horrified. Surely EA Sports had been paying off some of these magazines and websites? Actually, it turned out the best review that Pro Evo 2008 got was from IGN.com, who were, suspiciously, one of the main sponsors of the game; their billboard was all over the place and their logo in (I swear) one of the menu screens.

I played both games and witnessed my heart perform all kinds of strange dances. First of all, FIFA, which I played via my newly converted brother, made it beat quite a bit faster. It was like when you bump into that big-boned girl from the school that you left ten years ago and she is now as hot as hell. Then my heart decided that I was flirting behind my girlfriend’s back and guilt began to envelope me. I suddenly started thinking about Konami and the role they have played in the gaming life. I convinced myself that these feelings for FIFA were purely lust and that the love that Konami and I have shared over the years would definitely conquer all.

I was wrong.

I sat down with Pro Evolution Soccer 2008 a few days before it came out. Some game shop (it’s closed down now, incidentally) broke the street date and my flatmate had picked it up for his PS3 (the same console I had also bought a few weeks earlier). This time my heart sank. The game was lagging in SINGLE PLAYER. As for online, well you could well have been controlling Raiden from Mortal Kombat with the amount of teleporting that was going on.

These things were not the main problem for me, though. These could be patched no problem. It was the way the game played that really made my heart fall theatrically into a heap inside my chest. It just felt so last-gen. Everything I had ever dreamed of for this game was casually dashed away by Konami. Sex (I really need to dig my way out of these relationship metaphors before long) in the tried and trusted missionary position had gotten stale and EA had just bought a Princess Leia outfit and some silky sheets.

So, for the first time this side of the millennium, I bought FIFA.

pes09-6

FIFA '09

Before FIFA 08, EA had always strived for realism and always failed. The game was slow, sluggish and too easy. It played into the hands of the people who only played games once in a blue moon, dazzling them with amazingly well-rendered stadiums, deafening them with pinpoint commentary and allowing them to pop the ball into the net whenever an opening occurred.

Meanwhile, Pro Evolution Soccer went for high-speed arcade fun, without the fancy shoes and dashing hat. It was a series that stripped away the graphical prowess, allowing for the pure sensation of football to take it above and beyond the competition. Yes, the commentary was awful, but, unlike FIFA, if you were any good at the game then there was no way you would be beaten by some noob. It was a game of pride and glory.

Since FIFA 08, most of my friends have switched from Pro to FIFA. I’m talking about around twenty people who were full-on Pro Evo fanboys – those who’d argue endlessly with the few FIFA fans they knew – turning to The Dark Side. The difference here though was that we all suddenly felt like footballing Jedi’s, turning against Konami’s inability to find change within the stubborn walls of their gorgeous but now rusting Deathstar.

The Pro Evolution Soccer’s that have graced the next-gen consoles have felt rushed and, quite frankly, inferior to those on the last-generation. I always thought that once the PS3 came along, Konami would be able to improve both the gameplay and the sound and visual elements. This never happened at all. Neither side of the coin has been polished. The commentary is still awful, the gameplay doesn’t know if it wants to simulate football or maintain its arcade roots and it looks like a PS2 game.

EA Sports have clearly poured a whole lot of love into their game. They have re-animated every movement, improved the commentary, introduced (amongst other great elements) collision physics to the genre and made the whole thing look and play like an absolute dream. This is next-gen football as I always hoped it would be. FIFA finally achieves their goal of being as close to the real thing as humanly possible, while Konami is wondering what the hell hit them and what the hell they are going to do next.

I’ll be waiting.

really; as a new fanboy

Page 1 Page 2

Previous page
  1. Very interesting. I need to check out a “football” game; I haven’t played one since Mega Man Soccer for the SNES!

  2. @Chris,

    I have to admit, that is one football game I can’t remember playing. You’re more hardcore than me!

  3. avatar Gibbo

    Well I haven’t been as disappointed with the recent PES games but I can agree that Konami really need to decide where they’re going to take the series or I too will be defecting to FIFA. Infact I might pick up FIFA 09 soon.

  4. avatar GavinoX

    Wow, a really bizarre thing just happened to me, I was reading this article thinking “Did I write this??!” You’re absolutely spot on and the exact same thing happened to myself and my PES friends. I’m on FIFA09 and the thing that blew me away was the sheer depth of tricks and skills they’ve put in.

    I can’t help casting a glance over to PES though, like a guilty Man Utd fan checking if his LOCAL team has avoided relegation.

  5. @Gavinox,

    Thanks for that, glad to know you agree. It really has been one of the biggest turnarounds in gaming history – I really believe that. FIFA used to be laughable but it has stepped up ridiculously well!

    haha, I like the analogy… More fitting than the ones I mentioned about girlfriends!

    I could have gone on all day and night about what impresses me about FIFA. I guess the review I wrote on here covered that ;o)

    @Gibbo,

    I think it was how much I once loved PES that really made it more of a blow.

  6. Fifa 98: Road to World Cup. Greatest football game ever made

  7. avatar Sujit

    I don’t agree though.Yes Pro 2008 was disaster but hen 2009 is improved one.I plyed FIFA till 2006 but i switched to Pro 06 from that year.Since then i am playin Pro but i did tried FIFA 08 & 09 but i found they like 06 no changes(IMO).For me gameplay matters more than graphics.

  8. avatar Coverter09

    I can’t lie. I was a pro evo fan from back in the days when it was called International Superstar Soccer (go on Roberto Carlos up front for my old skool crowd, you know what I mean ;-) on the Playstation. But I burrowed FIFA 09 from a friend bout three days ago after various arguements about how better pro evolution 2009 was and thought I’d take a chance. To mine suprise FIFA 09 is a massive step in the right direction that my loyalties have been tested. I now own a copy of FIFA 09 and my flatemate can no longer stand the sight of me lol. Times change which Konami don’t seem to understand. Fair enough if its not broke don’t fix it but I mean c’mon the online lag is ridicoulous in 2009 which I was excited about. Touching up the graphics and shooting physics does not justify a years work by Konami its unacceptable. I’m not saying they have lost another Pro evo fan because I now own both. I’m just saying fix up Konami and fast before us fan who made your series as popular as it is by just word of mouth (no need for commercials galore) will be gone forever.

  9. avatar Coverter09

    Great article by the way!

  10. @ Coverter09, thanks for that.

    ISS was amazing. I remember it was the first game to introduce player characteristics like Ravanelli’s grey hair and Roberto Baggio’s pony tail. Also, the Cruyff turn on that ame was immense. I think we’re talking N64 when I got that one.

    Cheers guys, I’m really happy that this stirred up the right emotions and differing opinions… People really feel strongly about these games!

  11. avatar Ramso

    Good Article Daniel… I played FIFA 10 and I still find too slow.. yes Fifa always have great looks, but for football players, Pro Evo remain the game… no matter what. Until Fifa reach the same experience of real football… soccer fan wont go back to Fifa

  12. avatar Bocha

    if you must know, the reason benihd it was that I got it a few days before its release date, now to watch me play it there’s a review. Nonetheless, I appreciate you watching the video(s).

  13. avatar Jolie

    magnificent submit, very informative. I’m wondering why the other experts of this sector do not notice this.
    You should proceed your writing. I’m sure, you’ve a great readers’ base already!

    my page – traffic simulator

Leave a Reply